Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Girl Friday's avatar

How interesting that nicotine use has remained stable over time. I love your question, "What are the chances that, if e-cigarette uptake is completely unrelated to the decline in cigarette smoking, that it would occur over exactly the same time scale and in exactly the right amount to maintain a near-perfect equilibrium of overall nicotine use?" Thank you for being among the first to ask questions on why we're limiting THR to only one subgroup.

Edward Anselm, MD's avatar

Yes, the availability of lower risk nicotine mitigates the risk of nicotine seeking persons using cigarettes. So even among non-smokers there is a value.

Compare the current cohort of people who use e-cigarettes to the many patients who I treated in my clinics. With rare exception, they all started in their youth. There is a wide range of nicotine dependence. Some quit easily and some will never quit. Some are self-medicating. https://edwardanselm.substack.com/p/why-is-your-patient-still-smoking?r=fp3rx

It would be important to better understand self-medication.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?